Steel Bubble?
By Duru
July 4,
2005
By now, most
of us have heard of the woes experienced by
As I noted
earlier, March marked a month
where I finally got serious about commodities. My timing could not have been worse. Heck, even Doug Kass
fought the growing consensus as he proclaimed in a March issue of Barron's that
steel had topped. Regardless, I have
learned a lot while watching steel quickly fall apart. It turns out that there has been a bubble in
steel prices, and, as so often happens with bubbles, an abiding faith in the alleged
fundamentals provided all the rose-colored blinders I needed to ignore the
danger all around. However, as many
steel stocks print out classic bubble patterns, even the worst collapses have
only brought steel stocks back to the average levels seen in 2004. Our conclusion then is that either the bubble
has not finished popping and more pain lies ahead, or that there was only a sharp
pullback in a market that temporarily got ahead of itself. For example, the commodity index has not
followed steel downward. The commodity
index, shown below in a 9-day chart, indicates that the bull
run in commodities from the 2001 bottom continues.
Certainly the
Fed sees charts like this and sees the need to continue hiking short-term
interest rates. Sectors like steel that
are weakening should only get weaker under such conditions. I print below several charts of steel stocks
that I follow to show how mixed the two-year story appears. We have steel stocks which have clearly
popped short-term bubbles. We have stocks
that have been making slow and tentative recoveries from catastrophic lows in
March (see an earlier posting for
a more detailed look at the charts of Oregon Steel). Finally, we have stocks whose long-term story
amazingly remains intact. You can be the
judge, but isn't amazing that so many public steel companies remain after all
that angst we saw earlier this decade over bankrupt steel companies and
chronically poor financials?
Also realize
that in these days and years of bubble-talk, we have become highly sensitized
to what appear obvious bubbles (like housing prices around the globe and some
think oil prices are extremely over-extended), and nearly oblivious to
potential bubble-like conditions that remain off our radar because we consumers
do not purchase these goods directly.
Oregon Steel
dropped about 50% in less than three months.
Despite this bubblicious looking chart, prices
have merely returned to levels last seen in the fall of 2004.
The close-up
of Oregon Steel shows the development of a "do-or-die"
situation. The stock is below the (still
rising) 200-day moving average, struggles to cling to a declining 50-day moving
average, and tries to climb a recent up-trend in recovery from the sharp
two-month collapse. I suspect an answer
is around the corner…
CMC tries to hold the gap up
from late 2004 that marked the beginning and end for this bubble.
NUE is in a
similar situation to CMC. While a
mini-bubble has clearly popped, there remains plenty of downside. Erasing 2004's run would mean an additional
40% price drop.
Scrap metal
has been scrapped. An eradication of
2004's prices happened extremely quickly after SCHN failed at the highs printed
in January of 2004. Stay tuned on what
the market chooses to do with 2003's prices.
SCHN started that year at $6.67!!!
STLD has been fessing up about poor results recently. STLD's
bubble was extremely sharp. The complete
destruction of 2004's prices is only another 20% drop away.
And we end
this horror show with one steel stock that refuses to give up. While it experienced a quick run-up in price from
February to March, this run was "only" around 25%. The return to normalcy has simply returned
the stock to a year-long trading range.
The company continues to insist that things look pretty good, so 2004's
prices still seem safe. So stay tuned on
this one!
As always, be careful
out there!